How to choose the best compost for your plants (2024)

Compost is the foundation for healthy plant growth. A good compost will contain nutrients, air and water retaining ingredients and anchorage to provide stability for plants roots.

Some people are able to make their own compost. This usually means having large compost making bins or specially built bays where plant materials such as stems, flowers, vegetable peelings, grass clippings etc are added and allowed to decompose after a period of time.

For the majority of people however, compost is what they buy in bag which is then added to the border or bed or used to plant up pots or containers.

Different types of compost

Choosing the right type of compost for your plants depends on several factors, such as the type of plants you're growing, the soil type, nutrient requirements and where in the garden you will be using it.

Compost choice can be broken down into types of plants and specific tasks, but we’ll start with the most common type of compost…

Multi-purpose or all-purpose peat free compost

As the name suggests, this compost has many uses. A good quality peat free compost such as Miracle-Gro Premium Peat Free, can be used for pots and containers, planting in beds and borders, sowing larger seeds and taking cuttings as well as for growing fruit and vegetables. Multi-purpose compost can contain feed that lasts anything from 6 weeks to 3 months and has an open, airy structure with good water retention.

Seed and cutting peat free compost

Although you can use multi-purpose compost for seed sowing, you will get much better results if you use a dedicated seed and cutting compost. This will be finer with less nutrients and will usually contain sand or fine grit, allowing the delicate roots of seedlings to grow down easily into the compost.

The higher nutrient levels in multi-purpose compost can scorch fragile seedlings. Smaller seeds such as chillies and tomatoes should always be sown first in seed compost and then moved into multi-purpose compost once they have grown.

John Innes peat free composts

These are a soil-based compost that can be broken down into 3 stages:

  • John Innes No.1 – for seedlings and cuttings
  • John Innes No.2 – for planting small vegetables and plants in containers
  • John Innes No.3 – for mature plants or those in permanent planting positions

John Innes composts have more weight than multi-purpose due to the grit and loam within them so are an excellent choice for larger shrubs or trees that will be planted permanently in pots. The nutrient levels go up from no1 to no 3, providing the feeding requirements for the different stages of the plants.

Peat free mulches and soil improvers

These are used on beds and borders, traditionally in the autumn or spring to help keep in moisture, suppress weeds and add nutrients. Although not all mulches are specifically a compost many of them will be found in the compost area of a garden centre or DIY store.

Using a specific mulch rather than a multi-purpose compost tends to be a much better option when mulching a large area. Soil improvers can be used in most areas of the garden including as a lawn dressing before seeding a new lawn or just to improve the structure of the soil. Most soil improvers can be used as a mulch, but their main objective is to improve structure and make a clay soil easier to work with and a sandy soil richer in nutrients.

The types of mulch and soil improvers that you can buy can include:

  • Farmyard manure
  • Lawn dressing
  • Top soil
  • Garden soil
  • Composted bark
  • Bark chips

Frequently asked questions about compost

For more answers to compost questions, check out our dedicated compost FAQs page.

How do you know if compost is good quality?

When it comes to shop-bought compost, always buy a reputable brand so that you know the quality will be consistent and of a high standard such as Miracle-Gro or Levington. Homemade compost needs to be a rich dark brown colour and should be dry and crumble between your fingers. You know when your compost is ready as there will be no nasty smell, just a deep earthy smell.

What is the best compost for beginners?

The best compost to use in your garden will depend on what you’re planting. However, most beginner gardeners will likely start off with patio pots, hanging baskets, herbs or flowering bedding plants. For these jobs we recommend a peat free all purpose compost. For houseplants it’s always best to use a peat free houseplant compost.

Which compost is best for all plants?

For the majority of plants in your garden – whether planting in pots, hanging baskets, containers, beds or borders – a good peat free all purpose compost will cover all bases. But just remember, some plants will need a specialist compost such as roses, orchids or cacti.

Can I re-use my patio pots year after year?

You can certainly re-use them but it’s best to tip out all of the old compost and then give your pots a clean to minimise risk of pests and disease. If you have a really large container then you can re fresh the top few inches of old compost with fresh and remember to keep feeding.

Why shouldn't I use my own garden soil to pot up plants?

Garden soil doesn’t hold as much water and can lack essential nutrients, so plant growth will be slower and watering can be difficult. Garden soil will often also harbour pests, diseases and weeds.

How to choose the best compost for your plants (2024)

FAQs

How to choose the best compost for your plants? ›

Although you can use multi-purpose compost for seed sowing, you will get much better results if you use a dedicated seed and cutting compost. This will be finer with less nutrients and will usually contain sand or fine grit, allowing the delicate roots of seedlings to grow down easily into the compost.

What type of compost is best for plant growth? ›

If the compost isn't labelled as being peat-free, it won't be. For most plants, and for many seeds and cuttings, a good peat-free multi-purpose compost is suitable, both from an environmental and convenience point of view. Related content: Types of organic matter for soil.

How can you tell if compost is good quality? ›

Large particle sizes are indicative of incomplete decomposition. A foul odor is indicative of a too wet or too tight compost pile. Finished compost is dark brown and crumbly and has an earthy smell. The original materials should not be recognizable.

What compost do professional growers use? ›

Bulrush professional peat based compost is used by nurseries and professional growers to give excellent plant growth, flowering and fruiting. This is a premium grade, professional multi-purpose, peat based compost which is ideal for use in hanging baskets, pots and containers too.

What is the best compost to improve soil? ›

1. Oakdell Compost. Oakdell Compost is made with organic ingredients like poultry manure (a good source of nitrogen), wood shavings (carbon), organic straw, humic acid and other carbon sources. This soil amendment is truly composted, and is great for introducing valuable microbes to improve your soil's condition.

What is the best compost to buy for plants? ›

Multi-purpose peat free compost is usually perfect for pots and containers however hanging baskets and smaller pots which will dry out much more quickly in dry weather will benefit from a peat free compost that is formulated to retain water such as Miracle-Gro Peat Free Premium Moisture Control Compost for hanging ...

How do I choose compost for my garden? ›

A balanced compost should contain a mix of green and brown materials. The best compost for a vegetable garden is a well-balanced, nutrient-rich compost made from a mix of organic materials. It should be dark, crumbly, and have a rich, earthy odor.

What is high quality compost? ›

What is high quality compost? High quality compost comes from a carefully tended compost pile with the right mixture of brown and green matter, water, and oxygen. When all is working optimally in a pile it will reach high temperatures of 120-150°F.

What is one difference between garden compost and commercial compost? ›

Industrial composting facilities boast special equipment for breaking down compostables like meat, dairy, and fish scraps. Normally, these aren't put into a home compost heap because of foul smells and hungry outdoor pests.

What is a good store-bought compost? ›

Blue Ribbon Organic Compost is one of the most recommended bagged composts by gardeners, and it's easy to see why. This high-quality compost is made from recycled materials like brush, grass clippings, and leaves.

What is the best compost combination? ›

Aim for a 50:50 Mix of Greens and Browns

Think grass clippings, spent crops, old bedding plants, annual weeds (seed-free so you don't inadvertently spread them about in the final compost), and kitchen waste such as vegetable peelings and fruit peels.

What compost is best for perennials? ›

Perennials prefer a well-drained soil rich in organic matter. Prepare the first few inches of soil by adding peat moss, mushroom compost, bark fines or composted manure. Taking time to prepare the space will help your perennials thrive.

Can plants grow in 100% compost? ›

Compost is one of the best garden amendments available. You can plant in straight compost, but I suggest incorporating it into your sandy garden soil or mixing it with other additives if you want to use it for container plantings.

What is the difference between potting compost and normal compost? ›

A potting compost or 'potting mix' has added nutrients, which is too much for seeds. It may also contain green material, such as manure or recycled food. The compost is also coarser, with larger lumps. This makes it much more difficult for seeds to take root.

What is the best store bought compost for vegetable gardens? ›

Blue Ribbon Organic Compost is one of the most recommended bagged composts by gardeners, and it's easy to see why. This high-quality compost is made from recycled materials like brush, grass clippings, and leaves.

Does compost help plants grow faster? ›

Compost helps plant growth by balancing soil density. In soils that are too tight, compost helps to loosen the soil; whereas in compost that is too loose, it helps to clump it together. This balancing allows plants to develop healthier roots into the soil contributing to healthier growth.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Patricia Veum II

Last Updated:

Views: 6285

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (64 voted)

Reviews: 95% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Patricia Veum II

Birthday: 1994-12-16

Address: 2064 Little Summit, Goldieton, MS 97651-0862

Phone: +6873952696715

Job: Principal Officer

Hobby: Rafting, Cabaret, Candle making, Jigsaw puzzles, Inline skating, Magic, Graffiti

Introduction: My name is Patricia Veum II, I am a vast, combative, smiling, famous, inexpensive, zealous, sparkling person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.