Pennsylvania is popular for many food favorites; whoopie pies, cheesesteaks, and soft pretzels are only a few of the state's claims to fame. Cookies are some of the most popular foods available this time of year, especially in Lancaster County. But have you ever wondered what Pennsylvania's most popular holiday cookie is? You've come to the right place.
Pennsylvania's Most Popular Holiday Cookie
According to Google Trends, the most-searched cookie recipe in Pennsylvania over the holidays is the famous peanut butter blossom!
The peanut butter blossom was created in 1957 by Freda Smith. She made a thick, peanut butter cookie topped with a singular Hershey's Kiss to enter in the annual Pillsbury bake-off. Freda's cookie did not win first place, but it was a popular runner-up, sparking interest in bakers everywhere.
Later, Freda's recipe was published in a series of cookbooks. This ultimately launched the peanut butter blossom's popularity, and soon, Americans everywhere began to make the treat.
While this cookie is a favorite in all of America, the recipe is the most popular in Pennsylvania. Other states that love this recipe include Minnesota, Nebraska, North Dakota, Ohio, and Wisconsin. And even though the Hershey's Kiss was this cookie's first and most famous piece of chocolate, Lancaster locals will argue Wilbur Buds are the way to go!
Which Recipe Should I Use?
There are multitudes of peanut butter blossom recipes, some passed down in families from generation to generation.
Some, like my mother, claim that Amish cookbooks are the best for baked recipes. For your next holiday party, I've attached the peanut butter blossoms recipe from my childhood, straight from my family's favorite Amish cookbook.
Best of luck with your baking, and I hope you enjoy it!
Peanut Butter Blossoms
Ingredients:
- 3 and ½ cups flour
- 2 tsp. baking soda
- ¾ tsp. salt
- 1 cup brown sugar
- 1 pound chocolate stars (or Hershey’s kisses, Wilbur buds, etc.)
- 1 cup shortening
- 1 cup peanut butter
- 4 eggs
- 4 tbsp. milk
- 2 tsp. vanilla extract
Directions:
Combine all dry ingredients. Add remaining ingredients except chocolate. Mix thoroughly and shape into balls, roll in sugar. Bake at 375 degrees for 10-12 minutes. Top each cookie with a chocolate piece when removed from the oven.
References:
https://www.abc27.com/holidays/the-most-popular-christmas-cookie-in-pennsylvania-according-to-google-trends/
https://quaintcooking.com/2021/12/16/the-history-of-peanut-blossom-cookies/
https://www.hersheyland.com/stories/the-history-of-peanut-butter-blossoms.html
Big Valley Amish Cookbook
FAQs
This ultimately launched the peanut butter blossom's popularity, and soon, Americans everywhere began to make the treat. While this cookie is a favorite in all of America, the recipe is the most popular in Pennsylvania. Other states that love this recipe include Minnesota, Nebraska, North Dakota, Ohio, and Wisconsin.
What is the favorite Christmas cookie survey? ›
Among those who can make a single choice, frosted sugar cookies lead the list (32%), with gingerbread (12%) and chocolate chip (11%) rounding out the top three.
What is the state cookie of Pennsylvania? ›
The only state besides Massachusetts with an official cookie is Pennsylvania, which declared the chocolate chip cookie as their official state cookie in 2002.
What is the #1 cookie in the US? ›
Nearly 93% of all American households serve and enjoy cookies as treats or after meals. However, it's the chocolate chip cookie that's the most popular in the U.S. and around the world.
What is the least favorite Christmas cookie? ›
On the naughty list of cookies, Americans gave the lowest win records to anise cookies, which only won 29% of its matchups. Other low performers included chai sugar cookies (30%), pfeffernusse (31%), spritz cookies (32%), and meringue cookies (34%).
What is the most loved cookie? ›
What is the most popular type of cookie? It might just be this one. Ever the crowd-pleaser, the chocolate chip cookie is renowned for its balance of richness and sweetness.
What is Santa Claus's favorite cookie? ›
Chocolate Chip cookies
You can never go wrong with these classic, delicious cookies. Santa himself lists these as his favorites, and he prefers them soft and gooey with lots of chocolate chips. If you decide to leave these out for him, make sure there's a glass of cold milk nearby!
What was the first Christmas cookie? ›
1) Gingerbread
During medieval times, gingerbread cookies shaped like different subjects were a staple at fairs in Germany, England, France, and Holland. In the late 17th century, gingerbread became associated with Christmas. Gingerbread houses were introduced nearly 200 years later.
What Christmas cookies stay fresh the longest? ›
Cookies like shortbread and spritz are great candidates if you want cookies that'll last a while. In the freezer: You can keep shortbread and spritz in the freezer for up to six months.
Which cookies freeze best? ›
As a general rule of thumb, 'drop cookies,' which include oatmeal and chocolate chip cookies, and 'cut-out cookies,' such as gingerbread and sugar cookies, are freezer-friendly.
We nominate Mystic Flour Cookie as the rarest cookies in CRK at the moment, together with Special cookies (Sonic, Tails and the BTS Cookies, which have only been available for a short period) that are also very rare, and it's virtually impossible to obtain them at the moment since they could only be obtained via the ...
What is Pennsylvania's state dessert? ›
The pie for PA is a Shoofly Pie! The shoofly pie was invented by the Pennsylvania Dutch in the 1880's. It all started as molasses cake called centennial cake in 1876 made to celebrate the 100th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence.
What is the official state candy of Pennsylvania? ›
Pennsylvania House passes bill to make Hershey's Kisses the official state candy. The initial idea came from a group of students from Council Rock School District in Bucks County who were working on a civics project.
What is the most popular food in Pennsylvania? ›
Philly Cheesesteak
You can't talk about Pennsylvania food without mentioning the cheesesteak. The proper Philly cheesesteak is made with sliced and griddle-fried beef, with or without onions, topped with Cheez Whiz, American, or Provolone, on a long crusty roll. Copyright 2024 Nexstar Media Inc.
What is the name of the Christmas man cookie? ›
Gingerbread Men Cookies
No Christmas treat is complete without at least a couple of these fellas smiling up at you from your plate! An all-time classic, at Christmas parties.
What is the name of the town in Christmas cookies? ›
Aunt Sally's Christmas Cookie Company is sold to a large conglomerate and executive Hannah (Wagner) must seal the deal and shut down the factory, which is the small town of Cookie Jar's lifeblood.
What is the most eaten type of cookie in the United States? ›
What is the most popular type of cookie? It might just be this one. Ever the crowd-pleaser, the chocolate chip cookie is renowned for its balance of richness and sweetness.
